|

A.
Quick Overview of
Lipid-Modifying Drugs
The medications used for
dyslipoproteinemia include Statins (Crestor, Lescol, Lipitor,
Mevacor, Pravachol, Zocor), cholesterol absorption inhibitors (CAI –
Zetia), combination Statin+CAI (Vytorin), bile acid sequestrants
(BAS – Questran, Welchol), prescription Niacin (Niaspan),
combination Statin+Niacin (Advicor), Fibrates (Lopid, Tricor),
Glitazones (Actos, Avandia) and prescription fish oils
(Omacor).
☺
B.
Statins
Statins work by multiple
mechanisms. 1) Statins block the enzyme HmG-CoA reductase, the
rate-limiting step by which the liver manufactures FC/CE. A reliable
bloodstream marker of this reduction in hepatic FC/CE production
would be reduced serum lathosterol levels. The liver normally uses
FC/CE to form bile acids to assist digestion as well as VLDL
particles to transport CE, TG, PL, CoQ10 and vitamin E to the
various tissues of the body. 2) The diminished levels of FC/CE in
the hepatocyte cause it to up-regulate ApoB/E receptors which remove
large (primarily), CE-rich LDL particles from the bloodstream. 3)
When hepatic FC/CE levels are diminished, the hepatocyte also
decreases its production and secretion of small (primarily), TG-poor
VLDL particles. 4) Statins increase the production of ApoAI and thus
HDL particles to some extent (some Statins more than others). 5)
Statins also weakly inhibit cholesteryl ester transport protein
(CETP) and hepatic lipase (HL) and thus tend to increase HDL
particle size (and LDL particle size). By the way, since Statins
block the production of CoQ10 (normally made whenever CE is made),
some feel that anyone taking a Statin should also take a
good-quality CoQ10 supplement. Statins should not be used in
individuals with any ongoing liver problems but (despite what the TV
ads suggest) are probably quite safe in anyone with a "normal"
liver. In fact, in my experience, abnormal liver test in individuals
taking Statins usually represent fatty liver and what is really
required is weight loss and dietary changes. But anyone taking a
Statin who notices new muscle tenderness, weakness or swelling
should stop the medication and notify their doctor immediately.
Statins diminish
intra-hepatic free cholesterol (FC) levels to increase the clearance
of mainly large LDL particles, thus enhancing the ‘"benign" CE
circuit. 1) Through the inhibition of HmG-CoA reductase, CoQ10
production is decreased. 2) FC levels within the hepatocyte are
likewise reduced. 3) The resultant decrease in oxysterols stimulates
the activation of sterol regulatory/response element binding protein
(SREBP)-2 within the endoplasmic reticulum. 4) Activated SREBP-2
translocates to the nucleus and attaches to the ApoB/E receptor
gene. 5) Increased amounts of ApoB/E receptors are produced and sent
to the surface of the hepatocyte. 6) These ApoB/E receptors
recognize primarily large LDL particles and remove them from the
circulation.
Statins also decrease
the synthesis of endogenous β-lipoproteins. 1) FC levels within the
hepatocyte are reduced. 2) CE levels are thus decreased. 3) Less
small VLDL particles are created. 4) Less small (primarily) large
VLDL particles are secreted into the bloodstream. 5) Decreased
amounts of LDL particles in the bloodstream thus result. Since
Statins mildly increase lipoprotein lipase (LPL) and weakly inhibit
HL and CETP, the resultant LDL particles tend to be somewhat larger
in size.
Finally, Statins
increase the formation of ApoAI and HDL particles. 1) By blocking
HmG-CoA reductase, Statins decrease the formation of RhoA
Phosphorylase, an enzyme that normally inhibits peroxisome
proliferator-activated receptor (PPAR)-α. 2) PPAR-α can thus be
stimulated by its natural ligands. 3) ApoAI gene expression is
promoted. 4) Increased amounts of ApoAI are produced. 5) Increased
numbers of nascent HDL particles are secreted into the bloodstream.
6) As Statins are weak CETP and HL inhibitors, the resultant mature
HDL particles tend to remain large in size.
In
the lipid "shadow" world, Statins decrease LDL-C (removing large,
CE-rich LDL particles), decrease TG (reducing VLDL particle
production) and increase HDL-C (enhancing HDL particle production
and size). But the reason people take Statins is not to make these
numbers (whether lipid-based or lipoprotein-based) look "pretty" on
a piece of paper. People take Statins to decrease the future
likelihood of heart attacks, strokes and/or premature CV death.
However, if you look at the major clinical studies involving many
thousands of patients, Statins only prevented 20-30% of major CV
events in individuals otherwise predestined to have them. Another
way of thinking about these results is that 70-80% of individuals in
these trials who were otherwise predestined to have future CV events
and took Statins had those CV events anyway. Other forms of
mono-therapy (BAS, Niacin as well as Fibrate) have similarly
impressive (or not) CV event reduction data.
☺
C.
CAI and
BAS
Another way to decrease
FC levels within the hepatocyte is to block cholesterol absorption
from the gut. 1) Plant stanols (like Benecol – described above) do
it by diminishing the FC content in the spherical micelles. 2) CAI
(ezetimibe – Zetia) does it by blocking the uptake of FC from the
micelles in the first part of the small intestine
(duodenum/jejunum). 3) BAS (Questran/Welchol) do it by blocking the
absorption of bile acids (made from CE) in the last part of the
small intestine (ileum).
The most common of the
intestinal-acting agents currently used by physicians is Zetia.
Intra-hepatic FC levels are dependent both on the production of
cholesterol within hepatocytes as well as the absorption of
cholesterol from the gut. Some people are natural "hyper-absorbers"
while others are "hyper-producers.’" Most people are probably a
degree of both. Zetia has very few side effects and seems quite safe
although pregnant/nursing or otherwise potentially
child-bearing women and people with ongoing liver problems
should probably not take it.
There is some evidence
demonstrating that patients taking Statins eventually hyper-absorb
cholesterol from their gut as an attempt by the body to return to
balance. In this situation, other noncholesterol sterols that
are probably even more harmful than cholesterol (sitosterol,
campesterol, stigmasterol) may: 1) have their absorption from the
gut enhanced by up-regulation of NPC1L1 (see below); and/or 2) have
their re-secretion back into the gut and/or bile duct diminished by
down-regulation of ABCG5/ABCG8. Noncholesterols sterols seem
more atherogenic than cholesterol because there are no human enzymes
capable of esterifying them. Any unesterified sterol is quite
vulnerable to reactive oxygen species. Esterified cholesterol
(CE) is nontoxic and the inactive storage
form of cholesterol. Any unesterified noncholesterol
sterol (hydrophilic) is trafficked within lipoprotein particle
surface coats along with FC (also hydrophilic and usually 20%
of total β-lipoprotein cholesterol content). Increased β-lipoprotein
FC and/or noncholesterol sterol levels makes the particle more
susceptible to oxidation and incorporation into vascular wall
macrophages. Patients with CHD tend to have LDL-C levels >
100 mg/dL. Patients with noncholesterol sterol-induced
premature CHD have LDL-sitosterol levels > 30 mg/dL.
Thus it appears noncholesterol sterols are at least three
times more atherogenic than cholesterol.
Zetia
may be useful both as an alternative to Statin therapy for removing
primarily large, CE-rich LDL particles from the bloodstream as well
as an addition to Statin therapy to enhance LDL particle clearance
and potentially prevent the complications of gut cholesterol
hyper-absorption. A combination Statin + CAI product called Vytorin
is now available. 1) Zetia blocks enterocyte sterol permease or
Niemann Pick C1 Like 1 (NPC1L1) and thus inhibits gut absorption of
FC from the micelles. A reliable bloodstream marker of this
reduction in gut FC absorption would be reduced serum campesterol
levels. 2) Chylomicron and CM-R particles (having less CE in their
cores) are secreted into the portal lympatics. 3) Decrease in CM-R
particle delivery of CE to the hepatocyte via LDL-related protein
(LRP) receptors occurs. 4) The resultant diminished intra-hepatic FC
levels lead to increased clearance of large LDL particles and
decreased production of small VLDL particles. Note that NPC1L1 is
also present on the hepatocyte and Zetia therefore blocks
re-absorption of FC by the hepatocyte from the bile. There are
currently no published clinical outcome trials involving either
Benecol or Zetia but older studies involving BAS showed prevention
of 15-20% of otherwise preventable future major CV
events
☺
D.
Niacin
Niacin (vitamin B3)
works by multiple mechanisms. First and foremost, Niacin decreases
the synthesis of large (primarily) VLDL particles and thus leads to
reduction of small LDL particle bloodstream levels. 1) Niacin
inhibits the enzyme diacylglycerol acyltransferase (DGAT)-2, by
which the liver converts free fatty acids (FFA) into TG. 2) Niacin
thus decreases resultant intra-hepatic TG levels. 3) Diminished
synthesis of TG-rich VLDL particles results. 4) Decreased secretion
of large, TG-rich VLDL particles into the circulation occurs. 5) As
Niacin is a potent inhibitor of HL, bloodstream levels of small,
CE-poor LDL particles are likewise diminished. Niacin should not be
taken by individuals with ongoing liver problems or signs of active
arterial bleeding. Higher doses of certain forms of dietary
supplement Niacin have been shown to cause significant liver
inflammation in some individuals.
Niacin
also has effects upon HDL particle dynamics. 1) Large HDL particles
can bind via surface ApoAI to ApoAI, "holoparticle," catabolic
receptors present on hepatocytes (small HDL particles are not well
recognized). When large HDL particles bind to these receptors, the
entire complex is taken into the hepatocyte and catabolized. 2)
Niacin blocks these receptors, thus preventing large HDL particle
catabolism (a form of direct RCT). 3) Large, CE-rich HDL particles
can exchange CE for TG with TG-rich β-lipoproteins via CETP. 4) CE
can thus be returned to the liver by ApoB/E receptors (indirect
RCT). 5) Niacin also blocks HL and the resultant large TG-enriched
HDL particles remain in circulation. Although no longer capable of
conversion to small HDL particles, indirect RCT or SR-B1-related
direct RCT, these large TG-rich HDL
particles can be removed from circulation by ApoB/E receptors (small
particles are not well recognized) if they contain translocated
ApoE.
Niacin was the first
agent ever used for lipoprotein disorders as well as the first lipid
drug ever studied in terms of CV risk reduction, showing up to
25-30% prevention of otherwise preventable future CV events in a
study of hundreds of patients. The only form of Niacin that can be
recommended for use is prescription Niaspan (also found in
combination with Lovastatin in Advicor). All other forms of Niacin
found on the market are dietary supplements without any FDA
oversight whatsoever regarding safety, efficacy, quality, content or
lot variability. Over-the-counter (OTC) Niacin products (where the
FDA would be involved with oversight) DO NOT EXIST in the
North American marketplace. Multiple medical authorities have warned
against the use of dietary supplement Niacin, basically calling it
weak, unsafe junk that "must not be used." The forms of dietary
supplement Niacin include: 1) nicotinamide (completely ineffective);
2) immediate-release (poor quality); and 3) sustained release (poor
quality, less effective and associated with liver inflammation). For
your information, prescription Niaspan is classified as an "extended
release" form of Niacin and is safe, effective and of top
quality.
One
other important benefit of Niacin therapy is its potent induction of
vasodilatation (the opening of blood vessels). Niacin is one of the
most powerful stimulators of endothelial nitric oxide synthetase
(eNOS), an enzyme on the inner lining of blood vessels that causes
them to relax and dilate. Individuals with CHD, T2DM, MS/IR and/or
other states of high CV risk typically have low bloodstream levels
of nitric oxide (NO) and are vasoconstricted as a result. The
individual in this vasoconstricted state (which is harmful to the
organs and tissues of the body) usually feels "normal" since they
are acclimated to the pathology. As Niacin quickly reverses this
state, many patients who begin Niacin therapy initially experience
"flushing" complaints. These symptoms ARE NOT side effects,
allergies or anything BAD. They are an expression of the
patient changing from a pathologic vasoconstricted state to a
physiologic vasodilated state and resolve over time as the patient
becomes acclimated to the physiology of vasodilatation.
At the bottom of
this page is a copy of the instruction sheet that I give
to my patients when I start them on Niaspan or Advicor
therapy.
☺
C.
Fibrates
Fibrates are another drug class commonly prescribed for lipoprotein
disorders. They have prevented 20-30% of otherwise preventable CV
events in clinical outcome studies involving thousands of patients.
The safest and most effective Fibrate is probably Tricor. Like
Statins and Niacin, Fibrates have multiple mechanisms of action.
First and foremost, Fibrates decrease the production and enhance the
clearance of VLDL particles. 1) Fibrates decrease intra-hepatic FFA
levels available for TG synthesis by promoting their β-oxidation
within mitochondia. 2) Fibrates block DGAT2 to decrease the
production of TG. 3) Fibrates thus lead to a decrease in
intra-hepatic TG levels. 4) Reduction in the production of TG-rick
VLDL particles results. 5) Decreased secretion of large, TG-rich
VLDL particles into the circulation occurs. 6) As Fibrates decrease
ApoCIII and increase both ApoAV and LPL, VLDL particle clearance is
enhanced and bloodstream levels of small, CE-poor LDL particles are
diminished. Fibrates should not be taken by individuals with liver
problems and should be used with caution by individuals with kidney
problems.
Fibrates potently
decrease VLDL particle production and enhance VLDL particle
clearance. 1) Fibrates stimulate various nuclear receptors such as
PPARα within many cells, including hepatocytes. 2) This leads to a
decrease in the expression of ApoCIII which would otherwise block
ApoE recognition by hepatic ApoB/E receptors. 3) The production of
ApoAV is also increased which assists in "docking" VLDL particles to
hepatic ApoB/E receptors. In this manner, Fibrates directly enhance
VLDL particle removal from the bloodstream. Fibrates may also
decrease the breakdown of ApoB/E receptors by inhibiting an enzyme
known as proprotein convertase subtilisin kexin type 9 (PCSK9). 4)
PPARα stimulation promotes the genetic expression of LPL which can
thereby remove TG from VLDL particles (in the absence of ApoCIII
which would otherwise block ApoCII interaction with LPL). 5) TG is
removed from VLDL particles and converted into FFA. 6) The FFA is
taken up by muscle cells and metabolized to generate cellular
energy. 7) The FFA is also taken up by adipocytes and converted into
TG for storage. 8) The FFA also enters hepatocytes. 9) There FFA is
metabolized in such a manner as to decrease TG synthesis. 10)
Decreased TG levels in the hepatocyte lead to reduced VLDL particle
production and secretion.
Fibrates also have
potent effects upon HDL particle dynamics. Fibrates directly
stimulate PPARα within the nucleus of the hepatocyte. 1) This
induces the expression of the ApoAI gene (1) as well as the ApoAII
gene (2). Both ApoAI (3) and ApoAII (4) are thus manufactured. 5)
Nascent HDL particles containing ApoAI are secreted into the
bloodstream. 6) ApoAII assists in the maturation/lipidation of HDL
particles after being transferred onto them by various β-lipoproteins.
7) Circulating HDL particles tend to be small on Fibrate therapy
since, as soon as they become large and CE-enriched, they are
recognized by hepatic SR-B1 receptors (also up-regulated by Fibrate
therapy) and rapidly de-lipidated.
Fibrates enhance HDL
particle function. 1) Fibrates increase nascent HDL particle release
from hepatocytes. 2) These particles penetrate into atherosclerotic
plaques where ATP Binding Cassette A1 (ABCA1 – also enhanced with
Fibrate therapy) transfers FC from activated macrophages into them
in the cardioprotective process of macrophage RCT. LCAT (lecithin
cholesterol acyltransferase) converts the FC into CE (with the help
of ApoAII – also increased with Fibrate therapy) and the nascent HDL
particles become mature. 3) Fibrates up-regulate SR-B1 receptors
which recognize and de-lipidate mature large HDL particles in the
process of direct RCT. 4) Mature small HDL particles accumulate in
the circulation as they are not well recognized by SR-B1 but may
re-enter plaque to participate in further macrophage RCT. Note that
Niacin can also induce the production and function of ABCA1 within
activated macrophages in atherosclerotic plaques (via prostaglandin
D-mediated PPARγ activation).
☺
D.
Glitazones
Glitazones (Actos,
Avandia) function similar to Fibrates in terms of PPARα stimulation
(although they are probably at least four times less potent).
Actos is probably the preferable Glitazone since it is
equally effective in terms of blood sugar control but seems quite
superior in terms of lipoprotein effects. Note that availabe data
indicates Actos further lowers total LDL-P while
Avandia actually increases it. This may explain some of the
recent negative Avandia clinical outcome
data.
☺
E.
Fish
Oils
Omega-3 fish oils
function by inhibiting TG synthesis (1) as well as blocking the
formation (2) and secretion (3) of large VLDL particles.
Prescription Omacor should now be the form used rather than any
dietary supplement having no FDA oversight whatsoever regarding
safety, efficacy, quality (in terms of whether oxidation of DHA/EPA
has occurred – which is what causes fish to smell "fishy"), content
(in terms of possible mercury contamination – highest concentrations
in king mackerel, shark and swordfish, intermediate in tuna, lower
in salmon and lowest in krill) or lot variability.


|